The consistency rule explained
Updated
- Consistency rule:
- A rule limiting how much of your profit may come from one day (for example 30%, 40% or 50%). Most firms measure it against either your total profit or the profit target; each firm page states which, where verified.
- Daily loss limit (DLL):
- The most you may lose within one trading day before the account is paused (soft) or failed (hard).
A consistency rule stops a single big day from making up most of your profit. It is one of the most common reasons traders are surprised when they request a payout, and it works differently from firm to firm.
What the rule says
The rule caps your best trading day at a percentage of a base amount. Most firms use one of two bases: your total profit (best day ÷ total profit ≤ the percentage) or the profit target (best day ÷ target ≤ the percentage). With a 40% rule on total profit, no single day may account for more than 40% of the profit you are using to pass or to withdraw; with a 40% rule on a $3,000 target, no day may count for more than $1,200. Each firm page states which base the firm uses where we have verified it.
If your best day is too large, you do not lose the account (at most firms). Instead you must keep trading until the total is large enough to bring the best day under the cap. That is the hidden cost: more days of exposure, each one a chance to hit the drawdown.
The variants
Firms word the rule in different ways, and the base changes the math:
- Share of total profit: best day ÷ total profit.
- Share of the profit target: no day may exceed a percentage of the target, for example 50% of $3,000 = $1,500. Profit above that on one day may simply not count.
- Positive days rule: a number of profitable days, each above a minimum, instead of a percentage.
- Trading-volume or lot-size consistency: average position size must stay within a band. Less common, mostly at forex firms.
How common it is, and how strict
Rules are reported separately for the evaluation and for payouts on the funded account, because many firms only have one of the two.
Evaluation rule known for 75 firms, funded (payout) rule for 75. 46 firms have no evaluation rule and 47 have none on payouts.
| Best-day cap | Evaluation | Funded / payout |
|---|---|---|
| No rule | 46 | 47 |
| 1-20% | 2 | 3 |
| 21-30% | 3 | 4 |
| 31-40% | 11 | 14 |
| 41-50% | 10 | 6 |
| 51+% | 3 | 1 |
What happens when you break it
The effect matters as much as the percentage. A rule that raises the target is an inconvenience; one that blocks payouts can delay your money for weeks; one that fails the account is rare but severe.
| Effect | Firms | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Blocks the payout until diluted | 24 | Alpha Capital Group, Apex Trader Funding, AquaFunded, Blue Guardian and 20 more |
| Raises the amount you must make | 15 | BluSky Trading, FTMO, FundedNext Futures, FuturesElite and 11 more |
| Other | 6 | Alpha Futures, Bitfunded, BrightFunded, Earn2Trade and 2 more |
Worked example on a real account
The example uses a real product’s target and rule with a hypothetical sequence of days, starting with one strong day, which is exactly the situation the rule is designed for.
Earn2Trade GAU100 Gauntlet Mini: $6,000 target with a 30% consistency rule. Suppose your five trading days look like the table. After day 5 you have $6,300, which reaches the target, but the best day ($2,700) is 43% of it. To bring the best day down to 30%, total profit must reach $9,000: $2,700 more, without another day bigger than $2,700.
| Day | Profit | Running total | Best day share |
|---|---|---|---|
| Day 1 | $2,700 | $2,700 | 100% |
| Day 2 | $1,200 | $3,900 | 69% |
| Day 3 | $900 | $4,800 | 56% |
| Day 4 | $600 | $5,400 | 50% |
| Day 5 | $900 | $6,300 | 43% |
The lesson: a big first day is good news, but it locks in a minimum total. With a 40% rule, a $1,500 day means you cannot finish below $3,750. Plan for that before you celebrate.
Evaluation rule vs funded (payout) rule
Some firms apply the rule only during the evaluation, some only to payouts on the funded account, and some to both, sometimes with different percentages. A firm can advertise “no consistency rule” for the evaluation and still apply one to every payout. Our tables show both values per product when verified, and the firm pages quote the wording.
On payouts, the rule usually applies to the profit since the last payout. Each new payout cycle starts a new count, which means one big day early in a cycle can delay that cycle’s withdrawal.
How to plan around it
Practical habits that keep you inside the rule:
- Set a daily profit cap in your own plan at or below the rule’s share of your target, for example 40% of $3,000 = $1,200 per day.
- Track your best-day share every day; our consistency rule checker does the math from your daily results.
- After a big day, reduce size: the next days only need to be modestly positive to dilute it.
- Read which profit number the rule uses (net or gross, since last payout or total) and whether commissions count.
Is a firm without a consistency rule better?
For traders whose results come in bursts (breakout and news traders, for example), yes, it removes one source of delay. But a firm without the rule often compensates elsewhere: a higher target, a minimum number of winning days per payout, or a tighter drawdown. Compare the whole rule set; our no-consistency-rule list is a starting point, not a verdict.
Worked scenarios: the same days under 40% and 50%
Example (hypothetical): a $50,000 evaluation with a $3,000 target. Five days produce $600, $1,500, $400, $500 and $300, a total of $3,300. The best day is $1,500, which is 1,500 / 3,300, about 45.5% of the total. Under a 50% rule this passes. Under a 40% rule it does not.
To satisfy the 40% rule the total must reach best day / 0.40 = 1,500 / 0.40 = $3,750. That is $450 more profit, earned on days that stay below $1,500. The formula is general: minimum total = best day / allowed share.
A target-based version works differently. If no day may exceed 50% of the $3,000 target, the cap is $1,500 per day. A day of $2,000 would add only $1,500 at a firm that ignores the excess, or break the rule at a firm that does not. Read the wording to see which applies.
Worked scenario: a payout cycle
Example (hypothetical): since the last payout the funded account has earned $2,000, with a best day of $900. The share is 900 / 2,000 = 45%. A 50% rule allows the payout. A 40% rule needs $900 / 0.40 = $2,250, so $250 more profit is required first. During those extra days the drawdown remains in force, which is the real cost of the rule.
A daily profit cap helps in planning. With a 40% rule and a $3,000 target, a day above $1,200 raises the minimum total beyond the target. Stopping the day at the cap is a cheap way to avoid that.
Common mistakes
Where traders get caught:
- Computing the share against the target when the rule uses total profit, or the other way round.
- Forgetting that at many firms the calculation restarts after each payout; check the wording.
- Ignoring that the best day can change as new days are added: a bigger day later resets the math.
- Pushing size after a good day to finish faster, which increases the chance of a drawdown breach.
Checklist
Before a payout request or the last evaluation day:
- Which profit figure does the rule use (net or gross, total or since last payout)?
- What is your best day, and what is the minimum total it implies?
- Are all days included, or only winning days above a minimum?
- What happens on a breach: wait, higher target, removed profit or failed account?
A quick formula
To know the minimum total profit you need after your best day: divide the best day by the rule percentage. A $900 best day under a 30% rule means a $3,000 minimum total; under a 50% rule, $1,800. If that minimum is below the profit target, the rule does not bind and the target decides.
Figures and tables on this page are generated from our verified dataset (newest verification 2026-11-21) and update with it.
FAQ
What is a 40% consistency rule?
No single trading day may account for more than 40% of the base the firm uses: your total profit or the profit target. On total profit, a $1,200 best day means your total must reach at least $3,000. On a $3,000 target, profit above $1,200 on one day may not count. The firm page states which base applies.
Does breaking the consistency rule fail my account?
At most firms, no: you must make more profit before passing or before a payout. A few firms do fail the account; check the effect on the firm page.
Does the consistency rule apply to losses?
Usually not. It looks at profitable days relative to the base the firm uses, total profit or the profit target. Some firms also have rules on maximum daily loss or lot size that act similarly.
Do commissions count in the consistency calculation?
It depends on whether the firm uses net or gross profit. Most use net profit after commissions; read the exact wording.
How do I calculate the minimum profit for a payout?
Divide your best day by the allowed share. A best day of $800 under a 40% rule requires $800 / 0.40 = $2,000 of profit.
Is a 30% rule stricter than a 50% rule?
Yes. A 30% rule needs a total at least 3.3 times your best day, a 50% rule only twice. Smaller shares force steadier results.
Can I avoid the rule by withdrawing early?
Not reliably. The rule is checked when you request, and the payout conditions may require a minimum profit or number of days first. Check the firm’s wording.
Can I pass in two days with a consistency rule?
Only if neither day is above the cap. With a 50% rule two equal days pass; with a 40% rule you need at least three days of similar size.
Does a losing day help with the consistency rule?
No. A losing day lowers the total profit, which raises your best day’s share. Only profitable days dilute a big day.
Related lists and tools
Consistency rule checkerProp firms with no consistency rulePayout comparison